Stella D'oro Lady Stella Assorted Cookies Review

Stella D'oro Lady Stella Assorted Cookies
Stella D'oro Lady Stella Assorted Cookies
9.3/10
Excellent Our score
  • Five cookie styles in one bag, including iced citrus with sprinkles
  • Mini chocolate and vanilla flavored Margherite in the mix
  • 10 oz bag sized for sharing with friends and family
Check Price

Opens Amazon.com · see today's price & availability

A 10 oz bag that mixes mini Margherite, marble, chocolate and iced citrus cookies. Here's how this Stella D'oro assortment stacks up for entertaining and everyday coffee breaks.

Quick verdict

Lady Stella is Stella D'oro's grab bag: mini chocolate and vanilla flavored Margherite, marble cookies, chocolate cookies and citrus cookies with icing and sprinkles, all in one 10 oz bag. It's the simplest way to put out a varied cookie plate without opening five packages. The colorful sprinkles do bring a long list of artificial colors, which some households will want to avoid.

Variety 9.8
Entertaining 9.7
Coffee pairing 9.3
Ingredients 8.6
Value 9.2
See Today's Price

Pros and cons

What we like

  • Five cookie styles in one bag, so a plate looks varied with no effort
  • Mix of chocolate, vanilla flavored, marble and iced citrus cookies
  • Mini Margherite offer a taste of another Stella D'oro classic
  • 10 oz bag is meant for sharing, per the brand
  • Works for entertaining or a solo coffee break

What could be better

  • Long list of artificial colors in the sprinkles and cookies
  • Contains wheat, egg and soy
  • Piece count and the share of each style aren't stated
  • If you only like one style, a single-flavor pack makes more sense

Key features, explained

What's in the assortment

Stella D'oro lists five cookies in every Lady Stella bag: Mini Chocolate Margherite, Mini Vanilla Flavored Margherite, Marble cookies, Chocolate cookies, and Citrus cookies with icing and sprinkles. That spread covers plain, chocolate and frosted in one go. The package window shows the mix clearly, with pink-iced, sprinkle-topped pieces next to dark chocolate shapes and golden vanilla flavored ones. No other Stella D'oro pack we cover mixes as many styles in one bag.

Built for entertaining

The brand pitches Lady Stella as perfect for entertaining, and that's where an assortment earns its keep. Instead of buying several packs and arranging them, you open one bag and the plate already has color and contrast. Stella D'oro says the 10 oz bag provides enough to share with friends and family. It also works the quieter way: a few pieces next to your favorite cup of coffee, which is how the brand positions most of its range.

Ingredients and colors

Because this bag mixes several recipes, the ingredient list runs longer than on Stella D'oro's single-style packs. The base is enriched wheat flour, sugar, vegetable oil (palm and/or soybean), cocoa powder, whole eggs and egg yolks, with soy flour and modified soy protein. The sugar sprinkles bring Red 40, Red 3, Yellow 5, Yellow 6 and Blue 1, plus confectioner's glaze and carnauba wax. The cookies add Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Red 3, caramel color and titanium dioxide. Calcium propionate is the preservative, and the allergen statement reads "Contains: Wheat, Egg, Soy."

Where it fits in the Stella D'oro range

Stella D'oro began in 1930 as a small Italian bakery in New York City and grew into a household name on Italian-style cookies, breakfast treats and biscotti. Lady Stella is the sampler of that world, with the brand's Margherite appearing here in mini form next to frosted and marble cookies. If you already know you love one particular cookie, a dedicated pack gives you more of it. If you're feeding a crowd with mixed tastes, the assortment is the better fit.

→ Check the current price and availability

Lady Stella Assorted Cookies specs

Brand Stella D'oro (distributed by Snyder's-Lance, Inc.)
Type Assorted cookies
Assortment Mini Chocolate Margherite, Mini Vanilla Flavored Margherite, Marble, Chocolate, Citrus with icing and sprinkles
Net weight 10 oz
Key ingredients Enriched wheat flour, sugar, cocoa powder, eggs, sugar sprinkles
Fat Vegetable oil (palm and/or soybean)
Artificial colors Red 40, Red 3, Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Blue 1
Allergens Contains: Wheat, Egg, Soy.
Preservative Calcium propionate
Preparation Ready to enjoy
Package dimensions 10.98 x 5.12 x 2.48 inches
Model 200790105405
Prices change often. See the live price: Check Price

Who should buy it?

Great for

  • Hosts who want a varied cookie plate from a single bag
  • Families with mixed tastes: chocolate, vanilla flavored and iced
  • Coffee breaks where a little variety beats a single flavor

Skip it if

  • You avoid artificial colors; this mix uses several
  • Anyone eating them needs to avoid wheat, egg or soy
  • You only like one style and want more of it per bag

Frequently asked questions

What cookies come in a bag of Lady Stella?

Stella D'oro lists five: Mini Chocolate Margherite, Mini Vanilla Flavored Margherite, Marble cookies, Chocolate cookies, and Citrus cookies with icing and sprinkles.

What allergens are in Lady Stella Assorted Cookies?

The allergen statement reads "Contains: Wheat, Egg, Soy." Check the bag you buy for the current label before serving.

Who makes Lady Stella cookies?

Stella D'oro, the Italian-style bakery brand founded in New York City in 1930. The product details list Snyder's-Lance, Inc. as the distributor.

Do Lady Stella cookies contain artificial colors?

Yes. The sprinkles list Red 40, Red 3, Yellow 5, Yellow 6 and Blue 1, and the cookies add Yellow 5, Yellow 6, Red 3, caramel color and titanium dioxide.

Are Lady Stella cookies good for parties?

That's how Stella D'oro positions them. The brand calls the assortment perfect for entertaining and says the 10 oz bag provides enough to share with friends and family.

Final verdict

Stella D'oro Lady Stella Assorted Cookies
9.3/10
Excellent Lady Stella Assorted Cookies

Lady Stella makes one job very easy: putting out a cookie plate that looks generous and varied. Five styles share one 10 oz bag, from mini Margherite to iced citrus cookies with sprinkles, and the whole thing is ready to serve. That colorful look comes with a long list of artificial colors, and the label contains wheat, egg and soy. If those are fine for your table, we think it's the most practical Stella D'oro pick for entertaining.

Check Price

Opens Amazon.com · see today's price & availability

Lady Stella Assorted Cookies Our score 9.3/10
Check Price